HSE prosecution highlights the need for properly planned lifting

· 3 min read · Construction

By , Co-founder — Construction & Operations

A £4 million HSE prosecution followed life-changing injuries during forklift loading. The case shows why lifting operations need a competent plan, suitable equipment and proper supervision.

A serious HSE prosecution has highlighted the risks of treating loading and unloading work as routine.

An electrical wholesaler was fined £4 million after an employee suffered life-changing injuries when a load fell during forklift operations. The incident happened on 4 October 2024 at the company’s Proteus Switchgear Industrial Division in Telford.

The 40-year-old worker had been acting as a “spotter” while a forklift truck loaded heavy switchboard equipment onto a flatbed lorry. The equipment weighed 231kg. It was not secured to the forklift and fell on top of him.

The worker suffered brain and spine injuries and required lifesaving surgery. He can no longer do anything for himself or communicate with others, and now lives in a care home requiring 24/7 care.

What the HSE found

The HSE investigation found that the lifting operation had not been properly planned by a competent person. There was no risk assessment or lift plan, and employees had not been given information or instructions about the lifting operation, despite the activity being carried out regularly.

The investigation also found that the load could have been secured to the forklift using existing anchor points. The equipment had lifting eyes welded to it, meaning the crane attached to the delivery lorry could have been used as a safer alternative to the forklift.

Instead, employees were appointed as “spotters” and expected to steady the loads while they were moved and lifted. The HSE described this as an unsafe and unnecessary system of work.

The company pleaded guilty to breaching section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. It was fined £4 million and ordered to pay £6,304 in costs at Birmingham Magistrates’ Court on 16 October 2026.

The practical lesson

The case is relevant to any business carrying out lifting, loading or unloading, including small builders and contractors. A job that happens regularly still needs to be properly assessed. Familiarity is not a substitute for planning.

Before lifting begins, make sure the arrangements cover:

  • The weight, shape and stability of the load.
  • Suitable lifting equipment and any securing or attachment points.
  • The route, working area and exclusion zone.
  • Who is responsible for planning, operating and supervising the lift.
  • Clear information and instructions for everyone involved.
  • What will happen if the load shifts, becomes unstable or cannot be moved safely.

Do not put a person in the danger zone to steady, catch or guide a load when a safer method is available. Equipment, lifting accessories and the work area should be checked before the operation starts, and people who are not needed for the lift should be kept clear.

The HSE says lift plans should address the risks identified by the risk assessment and identify the resources, procedures and responsibilities needed to manage those risks. Check the current HSE guidance on planning and organising lifting operations before relying on an existing method statement or RAMS.

If you need a practical review of your lifting arrangements, RAMS or project paperwork, contact Pravise. The first call is free.

Sources and further reading

This article draws on reputable published sources and public enforcement reporting. It has not been fully verified case by case, so no individuals, companies or addresses are identified.

This article is general guidance, not advice about your particular site or premises. If you want it applied to your own job, the first call is free.

The short version

  • A 231kg load fell during forklift loading operations.
  • The HSE found no risk assessment or lift plan.
  • Workers were not given suitable information or instructions.
  • A worker was used to steady the load as a “spotter”.
  • Safer lifting options were available and should have been considered.

Need this checked?

The first call is free and genuinely diagnostic. If your paperwork is already in decent shape, we'll tell you.

Book a free consultation

Related reading

Contact

Tell us about the site, or the kitchen.

A short, no-obligation call to understand what you need. We'll tell you what's involved, what it costs, and whether you need us at all.